"I'm going to give it a shot," DiFelice said. "It took me 10 years in the Minors to get to the big leagues, and I don't want it to end like this."
DiFelice's contract will expire on Saturday, the date by which teams must tender 2010 contracts to players under their control. But since he was injured on the Brewers' watch, the team is obligated to pay his medical expenses during his rehabilitation, so they'll probably sign him to a Minor League contract. That way, DiFelice would work out at the team's facility in Phoenix and the Brewers could have more control over his care.
DiFelice has been on the disabled list since Sept. 15 with what was first described as "wear and tear" in his shoulder. An MRI scan didn't reveal any significant damage, and a second opinion from Dr. Lewis Yocum at the end of the season confirmed Raasch's suggestion of rest and rehab.
DiFelice was working with a physical therapist in Philadelphia but didn't feel any improvement in the shoulder, so he asked for further tests. An arthrogram revealed the damaged labrum and rotator cuff. "Would we have been better doing surgery back in September or October? From what the doctors say, it probably didn't make a difference," DiFelice said. "I would have missed most of next season either way."
Raasch inserted three tacks to secure the labrum and two sutures in the rotator cuff.
DiFelice has made an unlikely comeback before. It took him 2 1/2 years to fully recover from his first surgery, a procedure in 2001 to repair a fully torn labrum, and by 2005 his career was fizzling. Released from organized baseball, DiFelice pitched in the independent Atlantic League and then went to Mexico, where he discovered a pitch -- the cut fastball -- that gave him a second life.
He drew the Brewers' interest the following season and then pitched at a pair of Milwaukee affiliates in 2007. By '08, DiFelice was a 31-year-old Major League rookie. In 74 Brewers appearances over the past two seasons, he posted a 3.44 ERA and, working almost exclusively with that cutter, held right-handed opponents to a .218 batting average.
Now he'll need to make another comeback.
"The good thing is that I'm not a guy who needs to throw 95 mph, because that probably wouldn't come back after surgery," DiFelice said. "I throw 84, 85, 86, and the thing I'll have to do is find my location again. The doctor says that my chances of rehabbing and pitching again are pretty good. It just won't happen in 2010, probably."
Adam McCalvy is a reporter for MLB.com. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.