"The best pitchers are able to make adjustments very quick, and that's why some of those guys win Cy Youngs and some don't."
Crew chief Ted Barrett, however, said all the baseballs were rubbed up before Friday's game.
"They were all rubbed with mud," Barrett told MLB.com. "Mike DiMuro was working home plate [and is at third base Saturday morning]. Each ball he got had mud on it. I guess they weren't rubbed to C.J.'s liking, but they were all rubbed.
"No balls came out of the wrapper. Every ball had mud on it."
Wilson claimed the issue wasn't a coincidence, but Rangers manager Ron Washington rejected any sort of conspiracy with the baseballs.
"He mentioned to us [during the game] that C.J. thought the balls weren't rubbed up properly," Washington said. "We tried to accommodate it, but I've been in the game since 1970 and I haven't seen a game ball until it was in the game."
Alexi Ogando, Jason Frasor, Tanner Scheppers and Joe Nathan all said they didn't have issues with the baseballs when they were on the mound in Friday's win. Ogando said the baseballs were the same as always.
"They were good," Ogando said. "I don't know what was going on with C.J.'s balls."
"It's surprising, because people know what to do when [Wilson's] pitching at their park," Nathan said. "Some balls are different. I don't know why they thought there was an issue with it. Both teams used the same baseballs. It is what it is, and he spoke his opinion. Not something I would've done, but at the same time, everyone is entitled to their own way of going about things and how to handle stuff."
T.R. Sullivan is a reporter for MLB.com. Read his blog, Postcards from Elysian Fields, and follow him on Twitter @Sullivan_Ranger. Master Tesfatsion is an associate reporter for MLB.com. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.