"Clearly it's Plan C, and the good news is there are enough individuals in camp that can and have played first base," Ash said. "Of course, one of our players of the year last year, Hunter Morris, had a great year in Double-A, and he'll be a strong candidate. I know [manager Ron Roenicke] has talked to Alex Gonzalez about playing some there, and Taylor Green has played some there. I think our internal options are still pretty good, and we'll go that way, at least in the short term."
A humble Morris vowed to go about his business as usual.
"It's a big jump [from Double-A to the big leagues], and us talking about it doesn't mean I'm going to get the job," Morris said. "I have to go out and I have to earn it and I have to do a lot of things extraordinary. Doing that also comes with not putting too much pressure on myself. I'll be playing baseball somewhere this year, I don't know where it will be."
He added: "Opportunities arise in the game all the time, and it's up to me to take advantage of it. But you don't wish [injury] on another player -- ever."
Going with Morris, ranked by MLB.com as the Brewers' No. 5 prospect, would require adding him to the 40-man roster, a move the Brewers would have to make after the season anyway to protect him from the Rule 5 Draft. He had a breakthrough season both defensively and offensively last season at Double-A Huntsville, where he batted .303 with 28 home runs and 113 RBIs to win the organization's Minor League Player of the Year Award.
Gonzalez has only played shortstop in 1,559 Major League games and does not even have a first baseman's mitt, but he has seemed open to Roenicke's request to try the position this spring.
"I don't want to tell you, 'Yeah, I'm going to be an everyday first baseman.' I just want to wait and see what happens when they make a decision," Gonzalez said.
He knows better than anyone what lies ahead for Gamel. Gonzalez also tore his right ACL last season and had surgery.
"I know it's going to be hard for him," Gonzalez said.
Crosby is the most experienced of the internal options, having appeared 61 times at first base for the A's and Pirates, but he has not played in the Majors since 2010. Green has manned first in 18 Major League games and 27 Minor League games.
"We'll look at them early in the games here and determine [whether to adjust] later," Melvin said.
Had the timing of the injury been different, the Brewers might have looked at free agent Casey Kotchman, but he signed a Minor League deal with the Marlins just last week. Brewers officials don't think another notable free agent, Carlos Lee, would be willing to fill in on a temporary basis, considering Hart is expected back relatively early in the season. Veteran Aubrey Huff is also a free agent, and if the Brewers go the trade route, they could look at Mike Carp, who was designated for assignment by the Mariners last week, or Daric Barton, who is in A's camp on a non-guaranteed contract.