"We knew he was going to be the closer when he started the night, because we knew what our bullpen situation was," said Reds manager Dusty Baker. "J.J. Hoover was outstanding in the ninth. The guys I talked to, namely [Dioner] Navarro, who caught him [in the Minors], told me that the guy is not afraid of anything and he throws strikes."
Hoover faced four batters and gave up a two-out single before striking out Jose Tabata to earn the save.
"You don't want to get a runner on base, especially in a one-run game," said Hoover, who didn't know that he would be the closer Wednesday night. "I knew after they called on me they were trying to get the bullpen a little rest. I didn't want anyone else to get hot that didn't have to."
It's not Hoover's first rodeo, though. He started the season at Triple-A Louisville before being called up to Cincinnati in April. He rejoined the Reds in late August, but already feels at home in the big leagues.
"It's been great," Hoover said. "By the second week I was up here, it was like I was part of the team the whole time. It's a greater scale here, and the hitters are a lot better."
The Reds got their first glimpse of what the back end of games may look like in the immediate future the night before as Broxton, a longtime Dodgers closer, earned his first save as a Red in Cincinnati's 5-3 win over Pittsburgh.
"We knew there were going to come times that we were going to close with him," Baker said. "When we got him, especially when Aroldis goes a couple days in a row, we knew that was going to come up sooner or later. We didn't know that was going to come up like this, but we'll take it."
Broxton, who has chalked up 108 saves in his eight-year career, has been used mainly as an eighth-inning setup man since his move to Cincinnati.
The 6-foot-4, 300-pound righty said he feels comfortable working in save situations, but he's ready to pitch at any point when called upon.
"It doesn't matter if I'm out there in the seventh, eighth, ninth or whatever," Broxton said. "They're all important outs, and at the end of the day, they're all victories. It's always nice to pitch in, do your part and go out there and try to compete on an everyday basis."
But Broxton isn't the only reliever Baker will turn to with Chapman resting. Broxton entered Wednesday having pitched two days in a row, and Baker said he will likely play the hitting matchups and give a number of different relievers opportunities.
"[Broxton] is the No. 1 candidate. But it's matchups, too," Baker said. "If they have three lefties, it could be Marshall. It could be Broxton, it could be [Jose] Arredondo, it could be Hoover. Broxton is the No. 1 choice. We try to limit Broxton to two days in a row, too."
Aside from Chapman, Marshall, Logan Ondrusek, Broxton, Arredondo and Sam LeCure have all seen action in save opportunities. Marshall has earned the second-most saves behind Chapman with nine.