MLB.com Columnist

Fred Zinkie

Fantasy411 chat: Sizing up Keuchel

Fantasy411 chat: Sizing up Keuchel

MLB.com fantasy expert Fred Zinkie fielded questions from fans during a live Twitter chat (at @fantasy411) on Monday. Read through the best of the Q&A below. Questions and answers have been edited for clarity.

@Gadv_LeFrenchy: Is it time to drop Dallas Keuchel?

Fred Zinkie: Bench him for now. Don't drop him.

@DN1CE23: Please rank these starters -- Alex Wood, Adam Conley, Nathan Karns.

Zinkie: Karns, Wood, Conley. Wood has great upside, but he is inconsistent. I expect Karns to be the most consistent of the trio.

@JasonClark1907: Would you rather own Matt Wieters or Nick Hundley for the rest of the season?

Zinkie: Wieters. He has shown signs of getting on track in recent games.

@tommyc325: At first base, would you rather own Justin Bour, Prince Fielder or Chris Carter?

Zinkie: I would take Carter. He can provide the most counting stats. Bour would be my second choice.

@pdk233: Should I drop Santiago Casilla or Fernando Rodney for Brad Boxberger?

Zinkie: It is hard to drop Rodney right now, but I would drop him for Boxberger.

@atwalekLAB: Is Sonny Gray worth keeping at this point?

Zinkie: Yes, definitely. He could be an impactful starter once again by the end of June.

@dsep84: Would you trade Rick Porcello for any Dallas Keuchel, Sonny Gray or Matt Harvey?

Zinkie: I would trade him for any of the three. Of the three, I prefer Harvey.

@Snack_TimeFS: What should I do with Carlos Gomez?

Zinkie: You should drop him in a mixed league.

@TheHotCorner7: Is Alex Reyes a must-stash player?

Zinkie: He is a stash option, but he could end up working as a reliever late this season. They don't have a rotation opening.

@TheRealMamba_dc: Should I drop Justin Upton?

Zinkie: No. He has too much potential. But it would be great to keep him on your bench for now.

@PMiklich: Should I drop Billy Hamilton for Leonys Martin?

Zinkie: Yes, you can make that switch. Martin is offering an exciting blend of power and speed.

@Mike_Santulli: Would you rather own Brandon Drury or Melvin Upton Jr.?

Zinkie: Upton. His blend of power and speed makes him very valuable when he is hitting well.

@EasyMoney81: Would you rather own Ketel Marte or Jhonny Peralta?

Zinkie: Marte. He is not expected to miss a significant amount of time.

@Shiv1537: Is Kyle Hendricks a relevant rotation option in a 10-team league?

Zinkie: Yes, he is 10-team relevant. He should be used in almost all starts in that format.

@ljdobson9: What should I do with Michael Wacha and Adam Wainwright?

Zinkie: In a shallow league, bench them for now. Of the two, I'm more optimistic on Wacha.

@acsguy: What kind of starter would you take in exchange for Dallas Keuchel?

Zinkie: Try this plan: float his name to several owners. Find out which one still believes in him. Then go from there.

@alonaby9: Is it time to drop Kenta Maeda?

Zinkie: No, he can still be used in mixed leagues. But the sell-high window is closed.

@MRubinstein22: I'm thinking of picking up Tyler Chatwood. Is this a good idea?

Zinkie: In a mixed league, it likely isn't worth it. There is so much downside for a Rockies' starter.

@TheCalebHundley: Would you rather own Dallas Keuchel or Joe Ross?

Zinkie: I would rather own Ross. Less risk at the moment.

@JokeDelhomme: For the rest of the season, would you rather own Wilson Ramos, J.T. Realmuto or Stephen Vogt?

Zinkie: Realmuto. His ability to pick up a few steals gives him added value.

@bent0dd: Would you rather own Jonathan Villar or Elvis Andrus?

Zinkie: Villar. It's very close. Villar is riskier, as his role is less secure.

@Itslegend380: Where do you rank Noah Syndergaard?

Zinkie: He is a top-10 starter. A potential innings cap keeps him out of the top-5.

Fred Zinkie is the lead fantasy baseball writer for MLB.com. Follow him on Twitter at @FredZinkieMLB. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.