The Mets initially tried to make their six-man set permanent because they felt it was the easiest way to limit their starters' innings, Collins said, but they abandoned it after realizing how unhappy it made the pitchers and how significant a story it had become in the media.
"I didn't like the looks of it," Collins said. "I didn't like the feeling in the clubhouse that was going on. I didn't like the feeling. I just didn't like it."
Still, the Mets needed to find ways to limit the innings of Matt Harvey, Jacob deGrom and Noah Syndergaard, so they tentatively scheduled days for Gee or other spot starters to pitch. Sunday is the first of those, with the Mets in the middle of playing 13 games in 13 days. The rotation as a whole entered Friday with a 5.50 ERA over its last nine games, creating a perception that several of its members -- Harvey included -- could use extra days of rest.
General manager Sandy Alderson called his club's plan a "five-man heavy" rotation as opposed to "six-man lite," and the Mets now say this was always their intention. But there were communication issues. The team did not initially tell Gee that he would be starting so soon after his demotion. Nor did the Mets explicitly state their plan to use regular spot starters until Friday, after enduring days of criticism in the New York media.
"It's drama," Collins said. "We're living in New York City. That's where drama's made. So here's something that can create some drama, be blown out of proportion when it's very minor. I said from the beginning, we don't know how long this is going to last. I said from the first start, we just want to take a look at this to see if it's going to work. Obviously, we knew the reaction of the pitchers, and [the media] went in and felt the temperature of the clubhouse. Nobody liked it."
Candid throughout his media session, Collins nonetheless committed to nothing beyond Sunday, saying only that the Mets still consider this a five-man rotation, and that they need to find ways to supplement that with Gee and others throughout the summer. Injuries or other issues could still affect the plan.
"No one has a crystal ball," Collins said. "We do not know anything of what's going to happen down the road. We were so concerned with 'down the road' that we didn't realize 'down the road' may not happen."
Anthony DiComo is a reporter for MLB.com. Follow him on Twitter @AnthonyDiComo and Facebook, and listen to his podcast. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.