"There were four of us in the race that week," Ashburn said. "Hank Aaron, Stan Musial, Willie and myself. I remember Sports Illustrated did a big story on the batting title, and they listed odds for each. I was the last of the bunch. It really got me peeved."
Ashburn passed Mays on Friday, Sept. 26. "Whitey" went 2-for-4 to go to .3448, while Mays was hitless in three at-bats to drop to .3440. Ashburn increased his average to .3469 with a 3-for-5 game on Saturday, while Mays climbed to .3445 on the strength of two hits in five at-bats.
It all came down to the final game Sunday afternoon.
"My first at-bat, I hit a sinking liner to left field," said Ashburn. "Bob Skinner, not a real good outfielder, made a shoestring catch. I remember going back to the dugout and kind of thinking, 'It's going to be one of those days.'"
Right-hander Bennie Daniels was pitching for the Pirates. Ashburn singled to left in the third, beat out a single to third in the sixth and was walked by left-hander Bob Smith in the eighth. That walk led to a run which put the Phillies on top, 4-3. Pittsburgh tied the game in the eighth and the game went into extra innings.
Ashburn singled to center against another lefty, Bob Gross, to open the 10th. He wound up scoring the decisive run in a 6-4, 10-inning victory, coming across the plate on Harry Anderson's looping single. Ashburn hit a torrid .478 after Sept. 11.
Ashburn was finished for the season, a .350 figure. But Mays was just getting started on the West Coast.
"I figured the pressure was on him," said Ashburn.
The great center fielder needed a perfect 5-for-5 effort to tie Ashburn. Mays gave Ashburn a scare by going 3-for-5, which put him at .347.
"I really didn't know I won until sometime that night," said Ashburn. "I don't remember exactly when. I know the team was flying back to Philadelphia, but I had driven to Pittsburgh and was continuing on home to Tilden [Nebraska]."
So, Ashburn became only the second Phillies player to win two batting titles. His first Silver Bat came in 1955. Ashburn hit .338 to win by 19 points over Mays and Musial. No Phils player has matched him. Heck, no Phillies player has won a batting title since Ashburn.