As the ball plummeted toward the grass in shallow left field, Gregorius, who had played just two career games in Tropicana Field, positioned himself perfectly and made the catch to complete the Yankees' 11-5 victory over the Rays.
"It's something that everybody talks about," Gregorius said. "On high fly balls you have to try to stay with it. It ricocheted off the catwalk and I got right underneath it and caught it."
But while Gregorius never lost sight of the ball, the play got the best of Gardner, who had a harder time keeping track of the ball.
"I completely lost it for two or three seconds and then I saw it falling down," Gardner said. "I don't know why, but Didi was standing right there underneath it like he knew it was going to happen, so it was a great heads-up play on his part."
Troy Provost-Heron is an associate reporter for MLB.com. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.